The Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers in 2023

The Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers in 2023

Auto insurers decide how much to charge for insurance coverage after taking the possibility that a person may file a claim into account. Insurance companies believe a driver is more likely to get in an accident if they have certain red flags on their driving record, such as a DUI. The driver might thus only be qualified for high-risk auto insurance. This has an additional cost.

The Top High-Risk Automobile Insurance for 2023:

  1. State Farm: Top DUI Insurance
  2. Geico: The best insurance for reckless driving
  3. Best for prior at-fault accident coverage is Progressive

State Farm:

State Farm charges drivers who have been convicted of drunk driving a relatively minor surcharge. According to data, State Farm hiked premiums for drivers with DUIs by less than half of what many other insurers did.

Additionally, State Farm has a sizable network of insurance brokers across the country who may guide drivers through their options. Additionally, J.D. Power & Associates gave it excellent scores for its online services. State Farm offers discounts of up to 17% on insurance for drivers who combine their home and auto policies. Even if a person is a high-risk driver, the insurance company will cut their rates if they successfully finish a defensive driving course.


Geico’s rates for negligent drivers are roughly 20% less expensive than those of numerous rivals. This makes this insurance provider one of the greatest choices for those who have been found guilty of reckless driving.

Additionally, J.D. Power & Associates studies reveal that Geico has above-average customer satisfaction ratings. Additionally, it has a Better Business Bureau rating of A+. When purchasing multiple policies, adding safety features to one’s car, or finishing a defensive driving school, a qualified driver may receive discounts from the insurer. For motorists who have been charged with reckless driving, these discounts are still accessible.


In comparison to many of its rivals, Progressive’s premium surcharge following an accident is rather low. According to The Ascent’s analysis, Progressive’s premiums increased by about 48 percent after an accident for which it was at blame. Geico, on the other hand, had a 57% surcharge. Depending on where a person lives, an accident can have different effects. Actually, according to Progressive, the average premium rose by 28% countrywide after an accident.

A smaller surcharge guarantees that after a collision, coverage will still be affordable. Additionally, as soon as a client, Progressive gives accident forgiveness. Therefore, not all premium increases are brought on by crashes. Additionally, the insurer has an A+ Better Business Bureau rating, giving drivers peace of mind on the quality of their customer service.

Describe high-risk auto insurance:

High-risk auto insurance covers drivers who pose a greater risk to the insurance provider than the majority of motorists. It can be difficult to find low-cost auto insurance for high-risk drivers. This is so because the likelihood of a claim is taken into account when pricing insurance plans. When a person’s driving history indicates an increased risk of an accident, they charge extra.

If a driver is under 25 or has a driving conviction for drunkenness or recklessness, they may be required to acquire high-risk auto insurance. If they commit numerous moving offences or are at fault in accidents, they might also require it.

Nonstandard auto insurance is another name for high-risk auto insurance. Shop carefully if this is your only option for coverage. It might be challenging for someone with a poor driving history to find affordable auto insurance. Even said, some businesses charge far less than others.

What is the price of high-risk insurance?

Expect to spend 10% to 200% (or more) more than the average driver if you drive at high risk. Non-standard auto insurance has a range of costs. It depends on a person’s age, the nature of any driving-related issues, their residence, and even their credit score. It also affects which insurance company a driver choose. Some high-risk auto insurers specialise in providing coverage to drivers with a checkered past. They might have lower prices than others.

In general, insurance costs for high-risk drivers may increase by 100% or more. This is contrasted with drivers who have a spotless driving record.

Major traffic infractions including DUIs, reckless driving, and at-fault accidents typically lead to higher premium hikes. The cost of annual premiums for drivers with DUI convictions may increase by 200% or more.

A high-risk driver is what?

Any driver who an auto insurer deems to be much more likely to file an auto insurance claim is considered a high-risk driver. This includes motorists who:

  1. Little experience driving
  2. Several moving infractions
  3. Accidents involving fault within the last five years
  4. Convictions for drunk driving
  5. Convictions for reckless driving
  6. History of operating a vehicle without insurance

Most states also view drivers with low auto insurance credit scores as higher risks. Additionally, drivers of specific car models, including those of sports cars, have a statistically higher risk of being in a collision. They are also regarded as being high risk.

The top high-risk auto insurance providers:

Automobiles with a poor driving history are subject to increased premiums from even the best high-risk auto insurance providers. These policyholders are unable to avoid paying more than the average cost of auto insurance. However, these companies’ surcharges are less expensive than those of their rivals.

Additionally, an insurance company has different levels of severity for violations. This means that the cheapest option for an auto insurance policy won’t always be the one available to someone with a reckless driving conviction.

Each state has different premiums and options for coverage. Because of this, the best auto insurance for a bad driving record may vary based on the driver’s residence. Here are a few insurance companies that typically offer coverage for drivers with a history of issues at reasonable pricing.

Car insurance with the lowest premiums for high-risk drivers:

The most cost high-risk auto insurance differs depending on the state, the driver’s age, and the factor that makes them a high risk driver. However, the following businesses have a solid track record for offering affordable auto insurance for drivers with a blemish on their record:

State Farm: Unlike many of its rivals, this insurance doesn’t punish drivers who have DUIs as harshly.

Geico: Compared to many other insurers, Geico offers lower premiums for drivers who are deemed to be risky.

Progressive: For drivers involved in accidents, Progressive is a smart option. The national average of their premium surcharge is just 28%. This is less expensive than many other places.

It’s possible that these carriers aren’t always the cheapest. Prices vary according on a driver’s residence and specific driving history. Therefore, it’s crucial to obtain customised vehicle insurance estimates.

How to lower high-risk drivers’ auto insurance costs:

The cost of high-risk auto insurance will always be higher. Pricing to take risk into account is the foundation of the entire insurance model. But that doesn’t mean that rates for vehicle insurance for drivers with poor driving records vary.

To locate the most affordable high-risk auto insurance:

Compare prices:

Obtain estimates from three or more different insurance providers: It is particularly crucial to evaluate auto insurance prices because there are no standard surcharges for past issues. Consider contacting at least five businesses to compare premium costs.

Combining coverage:

If a person purchases more than one form of insurance, such as home and vehicle, the majority of insurers give large discounts. These savings aren’t forfeited just because a person drives dangerously.

Utilize further discounts:

Insurance companies may offer members of specific groups discounted premiums.

Only invest in the necessary insurance:

People should take care to purchase adequate insurance to avoid suffering significant losses. Yet a driver also shouldn’t be required to pay for pointless security. For instance, purchasing collision insurance to cover repairs for a driver with a relatively inexpensive vehicle might not be financially prudent.

Inquire with your insurance provider about ways to lower your premiums:[

Programs for safe driving are open to certain individuals. It might be simple to do that by installing a driving behaviour tracking app. If a driver demonstrates that they are driving safely, they may be eligible for discounts.

How to proceed if insurance is unavailable:

Auto insurance is a legal requirement in the majority of states. Never operate a vehicle without it. Therefore, check your insurance before getting behind the wheel.

There are primarily two choices for high-risk auto insurance for drivers:

Join a risk pool assigned by the state:

The state runs programmes for assigned risk. They act as a last-resort insurer for those who are unable to purchase private insurance. State eligibility requirements vary. However, usually a driver has to have had their own insurance rejected. People will be matched with an insurer that takes part in the risk pool by the state. The cost of the premiums will be much greater than with traditional insurance.

Collaborate with high-risk auto insurance providers:

These are businesses that focus on providing insurance to persons with a history of reckless driving. There are also greater premiums. The choice of insurance provider and type of coverage, however, may be more flexible for drivers.

Improve your driving record by taking these actions:

Try to steer clear of being labelled a high-risk driver in the future. This entails avoiding mishaps or traffic infractions. Also think about enrolling in a defensive driving course. People who successfully finish one of these courses will receive savings from numerous auto insurance companies.